Getting the Right Diagnosis

Why your reading at the doctor's office might not tell the whole story

📖 7 min readUpdated January 2026

📚 Part 2 of the Understanding Hypertension series

  • Office readings can be misleading. Up to 30% of people with high readings at the doctor have normal pressure at home. Another 10-18% have the opposite problem.
  • Guidelines now recommend confirming the diagnosis with home or ambulatory monitoring before starting lifelong medication.
  • Technique matters enormously. Crossed legs, talking, or a wrong-sized cuff can throw off your reading by 10+ mmHg.
  • Not all home monitors are accurate. Check validatebp.org to make sure your device has been properly tested.
  • A week of home readings beats a single office visit for understanding your true blood pressure.

In Article 1, we covered why blood pressure matters. But here's a question that doesn't get asked often enough: How do we know what your blood pressure actually is?

It turns out that a single reading in a doctor's office—the traditional way blood pressure has been diagnosed for over a century—can be surprisingly unreliable. And getting this wrong has real consequences: you might end up on medication you don't need, or miss a problem that's silently damaging your body.

When Office Readings Lie

For decades, doctors assumed the reading taken in the office was the definitive blood pressure. But research has revealed two common scenarios where that assumption fails:

🥼 White Coat Hypertension

Your blood pressure is high at the doctor's office but normal at home.

The stress of the medical environment—the white coats, the waiting, the anxiety—triggers a temporary spike. You might be diagnosed with hypertension and prescribed medication you don't actually need.

Affects 15-30% of people with elevated office readings

🎭 Masked Hypertension

Your blood pressure is normal at the doctor's office but high at home.

You appear healthy during visits, but your arteries are under damaging pressure the rest of the time. Your hypertension goes undetected and untreated.

Affects 10-18% of people with normal office readings

Think about what this means: if you have an elevated reading at the doctor, there's roughly a 1 in 4 chance it's white coat hypertension. And if your reading looks fine, there's still a 1 in 6 to 1 in 10 chance you have masked hypertension lurking undetected.

⚠️ Masked Hypertension Is the Bigger Concern

People with masked hypertension have the same cardiovascular risk as those with sustained high blood pressure—but they don't know they need treatment. Studies show about 40% of people initially diagnosed with white coat hypertension progress to sustained hypertension within 10 years, which is why regular monitoring matters even if your first out-of-office readings are normal.

Why Guidelines Changed

Because of these problems, both the 2024 European and 2025 American hypertension guidelines now make a clear recommendation: confirm the diagnosis with out-of-office blood pressure measurement before starting someone on lifelong medication.

This can be done two ways:

Home blood pressure monitoring — You measure your own blood pressure using an automated device, typically twice in the morning and twice in the evening for a week. This is practical, inexpensive, and gives you data from your everyday environment.

Ambulatory blood pressure monitoring — You wear a portable device that takes readings every 15-30 minutes over 24 hours, including while you sleep. This is considered the gold standard but is less convenient and not always available.

For most people, home monitoring is the practical choice—and when done correctly, it provides reliable information for diagnosis and ongoing management.

How to Measure at Home (The Right Way)

Home monitoring only works if you do it correctly. Small errors in technique can throw off your reading by 10 mmHg or more—enough to make you look hypertensive when you're not, or normal when you're not.

📋 The Correct Technique

1

Prepare beforehand

Avoid caffeine, exercise, and smoking for 30 minutes. Empty your bladder. Then sit quietly for 5 minutes—no phone, no TV, no conversation.

2

Sit properly

Use a chair with back support. Keep both feet flat on the floor. Do not cross your legs. Rest your arm on a table so the cuff is at heart level.

3

Position the cuff correctly

Place it on bare skin (not over clothing), with the bottom edge about half an inch above your elbow. The tubing should run down the inside of your arm.

4

Stay still and silent

Don't talk during the measurement. Keep your arm relaxed—don't clench your fist or tense up.

5

Take two readings

Wait one minute between readings and record both. If they differ by more than 5 mmHg, take a third.

Common Mistakes That Skew Your Reading

Each of these errors can add points to your reading—and they're cumulative:

🦵

Crossed legs

+2 to 8 mmHg

💬

Talking

+10 mmHg

📏

Wrong cuff size

+10 mmHg or more

🪑

Unsupported back

+5 to 10 mmHg

💪

Arm unsupported

+10 mmHg

👕

Cuff over clothing

+5 to 50 mmHg

🚽

Full bladder

+10 to 15 mmHg

🏃

No rest period

Variable, often +10-20

Imagine doing several of these at once—crossed legs, talking to the nurse, cuff over your sleeve, no time to rest after rushing to the appointment. Your reading could be 20-30 mmHg higher than your actual blood pressure.

Choosing the Right Device

Not all blood pressure monitors are created equal. The FDA clears devices for sale but doesn't validate their accuracy. Some monitors on the market have never been properly tested—their readings might be consistently off.

✅ What to Look For

Upper arm cuff

Wrist and finger devices are less accurate and not recommended.

Validated for accuracy

Check validatebp.org to confirm your device has been properly tested.

Correct cuff size

Measure your arm circumference and make sure it falls within the cuff's range. About half of adults need a size other than "standard."

Memory storage

Devices that store readings make it easier to track trends and share data with your doctor.

💡 Skip the Pharmacy Kiosks

Those blood pressure machines in pharmacies and grocery stores are convenient but unreliable. Many haven't been validated, they typically have only one cuff size (often too small), and the environment isn't conducive to accurate measurement. Use them for curiosity, but don't base medical decisions on them.

The Standard Home Monitoring Protocol

When your doctor asks you to check your blood pressure at home to confirm a diagnosis, here's the typical protocol:

For 7 days: Take two readings in the morning (before medications, before eating) and two readings in the evening, each pair one minute apart.

Then: Discard the first day's readings (people often have artificially high readings when they start). Average the remaining readings.

The threshold: A home average of 130/80 mmHg or higher suggests hypertension. This is slightly lower than the office threshold because home readings tend to run a bit lower than office readings.

The Bottom Line

A single blood pressure reading at the doctor's office isn't enough to diagnose hypertension—and acting on it alone can lead to unnecessary treatment or missed problems. Today's guidelines recommend confirming elevated readings with home monitoring before starting lifelong medication. Get a validated upper-arm device, learn the correct technique, and track your readings over a week. That data is far more valuable than any single office measurement, and it puts you in control of understanding your true blood pressure.